Regardless of how well we take care of our roofs, they will eventually need to be replaced. As it turns out, roofs can survive various kinds of weather such as wind, rain, snow, hail, and other natural elements throughout the course of time. Calling a skilled roofing company is essential when this happens.

Since no two contractors are alike, it’s critical to know what kinds of repairs most contractors can handle. A closer look at some of the most common roof repairs performed by a roofing company is necessary to better understand the scope of the problem.

The decision to repair or replace your roof will be discussed in this article from the perspective of an industrial practitioner. If you’re contemplating whether or not to have your roof repaired or replaced, keep the following points in mind.

What does roof repair entail?

A simple roof repair may be all you need if you encountered small or moderate roof damage. This might help you extend the life of your roofing system. It’s a decision that nearly every homeowner has to make. 

It is best to hire a reputable roofing company, even if the damage appears to be simple enough to repair on your own. You may go through “Why should you employ a roofer to repair missing shingles?” in the article below:

When it comes to roof repair, only a small, specific area of roofing needs to be repaired, rather than a full roof being removed and replaced. Damage to your roof may necessitate patching small holes and replacing missing or damaged shingles and other elements as part of the repair procedure. To begin with, you or a professional roofer will need to identify the issue with your roof so that repairs may be made.

Bring a pair of binoculars and assess the roof’s structure from the ground to see if there are any anomalies. There are numerous symptoms that your roof needs to be repaired: missing shingles, punctured shingles, burst nails, broken flashing, and loss of granules.

What goes into a roof replacement?

Repairing the roof is only going to fix a part of the building. However, roof replacement means the visible area will be replaced with a new one.  To prepare for a new roof installation, you must remove everything to reveal the deck and make repairs to the casing, rafters, and trusses, if necessary.

It’s also critical that you have insurance if your roof is damaged by extreme weather (tornadoes, and hail) so that you can have it repaired or replaced. If you notice that your roof is sagging, it’s time to think about getting a new one. As a warning indication, your roof may be on the point of collapse at any moment.

The process of replacing a roof is more complicated than repairing a roof since it involves more steps. For an average-sized roofing project, many contractors require three to four days or more of work time. Even if you go with a tile roof, a professional roofer can usually get this down to one day in most cases.

As with roof repairs, replacements require a thorough evaluation. Determine if repairs are sufficient, or whether the entire roof needs to be replaced, is the job of the roofer.

What is the difference between roof replacement and re-roofing?

Roof replacement and re-roofing are two different things. It is a common misunderstanding among home and business owners. It’s important to note that while both of these home improvement solutions replace your old shingles with brand new ones, there are significant variations between them.

As a general rule of thumb, the roof and decking beneath it must be replaced if there is mould or large gaps, missing shingles, moist shingles, or significant leaks. It is possible to re-roof your home even if your roof just has one layer of shingles and has only minimal damage or leaks.

Re-roofing is the quickest and most cost-effective way to improve your roof’s appearance. This isn’t a major undertaking in terms of time, effort, or resources like roof replacement. Having no need to remove any of the roofs is why this home re-roofing project is affordable. If you can match the old and new shingles, all you have to do is put the new shingle overlay or roofing material on top of the old, worn ones.

Although re-roofing is less expensive than a complete roof replacement, it doesn’t last as long because you’re only masking the damage. It simply serves as a temporary stopgap. If the deck is damaged, you can’t find it because there is no thorough check on it.

Factors affect replace or repair your roof

1. The roof’s age

When was the last time you had work done on your roof? The age of a roof can be an indication that it’s time to replace it, however, this depends on the sort of roofing material that was utilized.

In most cases, it is advisable to continue with the roof you already have in place if you paid for it a few years ago. The current roof should therefore be kept in good functioning order for as long as is practical. Just because a recent winter caused minor damage to a roof doesn’t mean it needs to be repaired yet again.

Most homeowners only replace their roofs once or twice during the course of their ownership of their property. In addition, even the cheapest roofs are made to survive longer than the average homeowner expects them to. Because of this, it is unlikely that you will need to repair the roof of the same house twice.

Replacement of an old or damaged roof may be in order, especially if your roof shows symptoms of aging such as leaks, mold growth, and other issues as a result of storms. Regardless matter whether you expect to stay in your home for decades or want to sell it in the near future, replacing an old and damaged one is more cost-effective than making frequent repairs.

Everything has a shelf life, including roofing materials. Asphalt roofs have a lifespan of about 20 years, compared to the hundreds of years that clay or metal roofs can last. When you install a new roof, you are more likely to get a uniform look depending on the material of your roof. The natural aging process of wood shingles makes this especially true.

A new roof will always have a different set of wood shingles than an old one. There will be noticeable patchiness if you merely repair a small number of your shingles. If your current shingles are leaking and you value aesthetics, you might consider a full roof replacement. Even yet, it’s possible that you don’t care about it at all. Homeowners whose properties are more visible to passers-by are particularly concerned about maintaining visual homogeneity.

2. Roof leaks

When it comes to roof repairs or replacement, a leaky roof is one of the most typical culprits. A leaking roof may be the cause of water damage to your home’s ceiling and walls. What you have to do is check whether water stains on the ceiling or walls. The bad news is identifying the source of a roof leak can be challenging. The good news is an experienced roofing contractor can help.

Whatever the cause of your roof leak, it is imperative that you fix the problem as quickly as possible. A small leak can easily turn into a much more serious problem, such as:

  • Infestation of mould
  • rot in the roof sheathing and framing

3. The size of the roof damage

Repairing or replacing your roof is likely because the current one has either worn out or suffered substantial physical damage. In order to make the greatest decision for your home and your wallet, it is important to work with a trustworthy roofing contractor.

Damage to a roof can manifest in a number of ways, the most common of which are aesthetic damage and structural damage. Please note that these symptoms differ significantly depending on the type of roofing material utilized.

Aesthetic damage:

  • roofs that look to have worn and aged
  • Growth of moss and algae

Structural damage:

  • old and rusted metal shingles
  • Broken or damaged asphalt shingles or shakes.
  • Components of roofing materials that have been damaged or punctured.
  • Broken or damaged asphalt, tile, or wood shingles.
  • granule-less asphalt shingles with bald spots

A complete roof replacement may be overkill if just little damage has been done to your roof. After all, the purpose of a roof is to withstand extreme weather for a long period of time. Specialists in the roofing industry are usually able to fix small areas of damage. If you have a leak in your bathroom or kitchen, it could be the result of a single spot of damage to your roof.

Repairing a tiny amount of damage is possible in almost every case. For example, a small hole can be mended. When simple repairs can save you thousands of dollars in roofing expenditures, there is no need to invest in a new roof.

If a roof is severely damaged, it may not be possible to simply replace it. Damage from a falling tree, for example, maybe beyond repair if it lands on your house. It’s time to repair the roof if leaks are visible all over the place, not just in a few isolated locations.

A basic rule of thumb is that roof repairs can only fix problems that affect less than 30% of the roof surface. A new roof will almost certainly be necessary if the damage is severe enough.

4. Location

It’s important to know whether or not you live in an area prone to hail, hurricane, or tornado storms. A storm-damaged roof may require immediate replacement of any missing shingles or other roofing materials in order to avoid further problems, such as leaks.

Hail and falling debris can harm your roof’s long-term performance such as its appearance and waterproofing.

A new roof may be necessary if your home has been destroyed by a natural calamity. For example, even if the damage appears to be contained, your roof’s structural integrity may be significantly compromised if a storm or tornado passes through your location.

It appears that some households will be able to survive local calamities without major damage to their roofs. Damage from a hurricane or tornado, on the other hand, can sometimes go undetected. In the event of a catastrophic occurrence, even if your roof is covered by one of the strongest and most durable materials on the market, you may need to have it replaced.

If this is the case, a roof inspection is the best way to find out.

5. Budget

A key consideration for homeowners is how much it will cost to replace their roofs. 

Repairing your roof instead of replacing it can save you hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Even though an issue with your roof appears severe at first, it may only cost a few hundred dollars to fix. Regardless of one’s financial situation, saving money is always a good thing.

The cost of a new roof may be prohibitive for the average homeowner. While it’s possible to find out about a leaky roof in the middle of the night, it’s also possible that you’ve already made plans for several months’ worth of loan repayments, vacations, and the purchase of a new automobile. However, that leak may just demand repairs to a particular area of your roof, which would be significantly more cost-effective in a short time.

Roof repairs are often less expensive than replacing the entire roof. But, if they’re done on a regular basis, they could end up costing more than replacing the complete roof.

To help you decide on the most cost-effective solution without compromising the structural integrity of your home, your roofing contractor can provide estimates and roofing financing options.

In the long term, a complete roof replacement will save you money, especially if your roof has multiple failure points. The security of knowing that your most valuable items are protected by a new roof is another benefit of getting a new roof.

6. The appearance of your home

As much as possible, some roofs should be preserved in their original form. The outside appearance of a building is always altered when a new roof is installed. A critical architectural component has been replaced, and the property is no longer what it was before. The architectural integrity of a home can be preserved through roof repairs.

Even if you need to make repairs to your home, you’ll want to keep it as close to its original form as possible, no matter how much work you have to do. Keep the house’s original appearance with simple roof repairs. Only a little portion of the roof will need to be replaced.

7. Building regulations

If you want to keep your property up to date with modern building standards, a new roof may be your only option. Installing new shingles over old, damaged ones can save money, but only two layers of shingles are allowed by building code. Consequently, if you have already tried this approach, your next round of roofing problems would signal that a roof replacement is required.

To sell your house in the future, you may have difficulties if your roof does not match modern building requirements. So that you can at least be aware of where your property stands in terms of local legal compliance, get this issue reviewed the next time a roofing professional inspects your current roof.

8. Short-run VS Long-run

Even if installing a brand new roof is more expensive, the difference in cost is not insurmountable. As a matter of fact, in certain cases, the cost difference between repairing and replacing a roof is so negligible that you may as well go with the latter.

A new roof may be desirable if the repair costs are only $500 to $1,000 more than the new roof costs, which would bring your total to over four figures. Repairs may only add another four or five years to the roof’s usable life if it is nearing the end of its useful life. Because you’ll need it in a few years, you’ll pay about the same for it regardless.

9. Your desire

When looking at a home from the street, a newly installed roof has the greatest visual impact on the exterior of the building. If you’re looking to give your home a facelift, a new roof could be one of the most crucial investments. No matter what type of material is used, new roofs are always visually exciting.

Your house may feel more like it did when it was originally built again if your current roof is comprised of new wood shingles instead of old, silvery ones. Even if your roof is made of a durable material that will survive for decades, replacing it could give your home a fresh new look and increase its resale value if you decide to sell in the following decade.

10. Do you intend to stay here for a long time?

You may need to replace your roof if you plan on staying in your current residence for a long period of time. You can have a tough time selling your home in the future, depending on the state of your roof.

The sooner you have a roofer come out and look at it, the better off you’ll be if you’re planning on staying in your home for the long term. Determine if anything has to be taken care of. A professional roof inspection should be performed at least once a year, if not twice. If your roof looks to be in good condition. As a result, you may expect a long service life from your roof.

If you plan on selling your home in the future, you’ll have a tough time doing so if your roof is damaged or unkempt. Your best choice may be to have a new roof installed. It will be easier for you to sell your house if you have a new roof. When you sell, you’ll get back most of the purchase price.

Roof-repair advantages


Repairing a roof is less expensive than replacing a whole roof.

Repairing rather than replacing a roof is a more cost-effective option. In some places, elements of your roof system are less durable than the rest of it.

Extend roof lifespan

You can increase the lifespan of your roof by performing roof repairs.

Make repairs to your roof instead of replacing it, and ask your roofer for advice. If you don’t have a reason to replace your roof, you can extend its life by making a repair. There’s nothing else to say.

Roof-repair disadvantages

Match shingle colors for a roof repair is difficult

When it comes to repairing a roof, finding shingles with the exact same color might be difficult.

Shingles will lighten over time because of the sun’s rays. Therefore, it may be difficult to match an altered shingle. Getting your old shingles to match your new ones is practically difficult. Even your neighbors will notice the unappealing appearance of your property.

Poor workmanship

Roof leaks are only one of the many problems that can arise as a result of subpar construction.

Repairing a roof is a difficult task that should only be attempted by someone with extensive experience in the sector. Two entirely separate tasks: repairing and putting in place. Any more damage can be done by someone who doesn’t know what they’re doing.

Roof replacement advantages

Improves the appearance of your property

The value of your home rises when you install a new roof. You can either draw or turn away potential buyers based on the appearance of your home’s exterior. It will move from the negative to the positive whenever a replacement is found.

A new roof gives the appearance of a newer house when you replace an old, worn-out one. The replacement will not only provide you years of peace of mind, but it will also make your home the most beautiful on the street.

Sense of security

Having a new roof means that you may go on vacation without worrying about the weather at home. When you return, you won’t be greeted by any damage or leaks. Isn’t that wonderful?

Roof Replacement disadvantages


When a roof is being replaced, many people prefer to stay at home. As the shingles are being installed, they have no idea how noisy it will be inside the house. Clients should prepare to be away from their properties during the shingle installation process.

Remove your pet

Consider your dogs, despite the fact that you know it will be very impossible for you to stay indoors throughout the construction period. Many customers have opted to leave their pets at home while the roof is being installed. A daycare center for dogs or cats, or the services of a trusted friend, may be an option for you.

No cleanup

After a roof replacement, many roofing companies don’t do a very good job of cleaning up the mess.

When it comes to residential roof replacements, most contractors will finish 90% of the work and collect the payment before moving on to the next job. Who cares about the remaining ten percent?

Inspection and cleanup should take up the final 10% of a roofer’s time after a project is completed. Nails in the yard, debris in your shrubs, and flat tyres for your family and friends will be left behind by a shoddy clean-up.

In addition, it transforms your attic into a war zone. Everything in your attic, including your holiday decorations and other valuables, will get damaged if the roofer you employ does not use plastic or a tarp to protect it.

I’m at a loss on what to do next

Before you put pen to paper, here are a few things to keep in mind.

Research is a must-do step before you make any decision.

Before scheduling an appointment for a roof check, do some research on local roofing businesses. If you don’t know what to ask a salesperson or a roofer, you won’t be able to ask the right questions.

Not only that. But, educating yourself is essential so that you do not end up needing to replace your roof prematurely because you were duped. Before making a final decision, have a look at each company’s client feedback to see if they can answer any questions you may have.

Consult with another expert

Ask for a second or third opinion from other roofing companies if a salesperson claims that your roof is in need of replacement. Homeowners that required only a modest repair received five estimates from different roofing companies for a new roof.

Choose a company that has a history of doing the right thing, giving you honest answers, and educating you so you know exactly what your money is going toward if you get conflicting answers from the organization you’re working with.

Choose a reputable roofing business in your area

Choosing a local roofing contractor you can trust is essential. To find the best local roofing company, you must do your homework. Having a local office isn’t mandatory for all roofing companies.

Check to see if everybody you hire has a valid license. Make sure to ask the right questions and build a relationship with the company that will do the work.

That’s why it’s so important to keep an eye on your roof. The most important part of your house is its roof.